I previously wrote about a WWF-style smackdown among Mohler, Giberson and Coyne, and the verbal jousting continues. Uncle Karl recently wrote a piece in the Huffington Post basically saying that atheists need to learn a bit more about church, maybe even by attending one, before they bomb religion with the petard of rationalism. Coyne quickly responded with a post at WEIT - interestingly penned by the shadowy Sigmund who runs his own commentary at the Sneer Review. It seems as though Coyne has turned over his BioLogos-and-Company critiques to Sigmund, who apparently keeps a close eye on the BioLogos website, former BL vice president Giberson, and other science-religion accommodationists.
For me, both camps make some good points, and by reading both pieces, you can decide for yourself what does or does not resonate with you. I am currently working on a post entitled The Limits of Religion in which I hope to explore the relationships among the church, state and science.